Engineering Insight
ETFE Cushions and Hail: Punctures, Pressure Loss and Repair
ETFE foil is highly elastic, and a cushion at design pressure absorbs most hail impact by elastic deformation. The main risk lies elsewhere: a cushion gone soft from a blocked filter, a faulty fan or a power cut, small holes invisible from below, and hail held in low spots. After heavy hail, check air-unit alarms, cushion shape and drainage from safe access, and repair any hole before it grows.
Problem
After an autumn hailstorm: an air-unit alarm, a cushion that changed shape, and a noise that worried everyone
In recent days, weather warnings for Tehran and several other provinces have forecast showers, thunderstorms, strong wind and possible hail. For anyone operating an atrium, a mall roof, a botanical enclosure or a sports venue covered with ETFE, hail raises specific questions. Can foil this thin be punctured? Did the loud drumming of hail mean damage? Why does one cushion look slacker after the storm, or why is the air-unit warning light on? These questions cannot be answered with the logic of glass or polycarbonate. An ETFE cushion is a pneumatic skin: several foil layers clamped around their perimeter in aluminium extrusions, taking their shape and stiffness from low-pressure air that an inflation unit supplies continuously. Its behaviour under hail therefore depends at the same time on the foil itself, on the internal pressure at the moment of impact, and on the health of the air network. Any damage found after a hailstorm, however small, should be assessed within that system logic, not as a simple tear in a sheet.
- An air-unit alarm, or both fans running together for long periods after a hailstorm, can indicate air leaking from one or more cushions.
- A cushion that looks slacker, lower or more wrinkled than its neighbours has probably lost its design pressure.
- Small holes caused by hail or wind-blown debris are usually invisible from below and only show up through close inspection or the behaviour of the pressure readings.
- Hail and ice collect in the valleys between cushions, in gutters and along the extrusions; if drainage is blocked, they create local load and standing water.
- Hail impact on foil is clearly audible in the space below; the noise alone is not a sign of damage, but it is an operational acoustic issue.
- In a single-layer foil roof a hole is a direct path for water and air; in a multi-layer cushion the inner layers still separate the interior.
Engineering cause
Foil elasticity, inflation pressure and air-unit health together decide how ETFE behaves under hail
ETFE is a highly elastic polymer that tolerates large deformation before it breaks. A cushion inflated to its design pressure acts like a taut surface: the hailstone strikes, the foil dips locally, and the impact energy is spread through elastic deformation of the foil and compression of the air inside. Manufacturers' technical sources also stress that, with proper design, ETFE can withstand hail strikes. Proper design here means an outer-layer thickness chosen for the anticipated loads and span, suitable cushion geometry and curvature, and pressure maintained while the hail is falling. When internal pressure has dropped, for example because of a blocked filter, a faulty fan, a leaking non-return valve, a disconnected air pipe or a power cut without standby power, the cushion goes soft, the outer layer sags, and hail and water collect in the hollows. Load is then concentrated on small areas and edges instead of being spread over a taut surface, and creasing, contact between layers and local damage become more likely. Tear behaviour matters too. ETFE has little notch sensitivity: a small cut first runs a little, then the material stretches and its edge rounds out. Even so, an unrepaired hole causes a permanent air leak and keeps the fans running continuously. In typical systems the air unit raises airflow when pressure drops and compensates for minor leaks, but that compensation only buys time; it is not a repair.
- Outer-layer thickness is selected for anticipated loads, span and application; a layer chosen only for transparency or weight may lack margin.
- A soft cushion loses stiffness and holds hail and water in a hollow; at the moment of impact, internal pressure matters as much as the foil itself.
- A blocked filter, a fan without backup, a faulty non-return valve or a loose pipe joint lowers pressure exactly when it is needed most.
- A power cut during a storm without standby power means cushions slowly lose pressure and the safety margin against the next load shrinks.
- Shallow cushion curvature or insufficient fall in valleys and gutters lets hail and water stay on the roof and concentrates load.
- A small unrepaired hole keeps the fans running continuously and can grow into larger damage in the next wind or snow event.
Technical proof or diagram
Technical proof state
No metric, project result, or proof image is shown until a verified asset is attached.
The verified diagram should compare a section through a multi-layer cushion in two states: at design pressure, with a taut outer layer spreading the impact, and at reduced pressure, with a sagging outer layer and hail and water collected in the hollow and along the extrusion. Beside it, the air path from the inflation unit and filter through the non-return valve to the cushion, and the location of the low-pressure alarm, should be shown. This technical asset is still pending verification.
- Taut outer layer at design pressure
- Hollow and hail build-up in a soft cushion
- Inflation unit, filter and non-return valve
- Valley, gutter and drainage path
SIPANEL solution logic
SIPANEL's logic for preparing and inspecting ETFE roofs in the hail season
Review design assumptions and foil specification
For a new roof, site environmental loads including hail, snow and wind are reviewed together with span and cushion geometry, so that outer-layer thickness, layer count and curvature are selected from the system manufacturer's data. For an existing roof, foil records and design assumptions are collected before any judgement about damage.
An air network with redundancy and standby power
The air unit is defined with a backup fan, non-return valves, zoning and pressure monitoring, and the power-cut scenario, standby power and response time are written into the operating instructions. Where the system is designed for it, a temporary pressure increase during high wind or heavy snow is also defined.
Preparation before the wet season
Filters are replaced, both fans and the alarms are tested, pipe connections and extrusions are checked, and valleys, gutters and drainage paths are cleared of dust and leaves so that hail and water do not stay on the surface.
Response during and immediately after hail
Alarms and pressure are monitored. Nobody walks on the foil, and any area that took impacts is treated as fragile until inspected. If a zone shows a persistent pressure drop, access beneath it is restricted and the event is logged.
Systematic post-storm inspection
From safe access routes or by rope access, cushions are checked for holes, scratches, wrinkles and distortion, edges and clamps for displacement, and valleys for ice build-up. Fan running records are compared with the pre-storm condition to reveal hidden leaks.
Repair matched to the size of the damage
Small holes and tears are repaired in place with dedicated ETFE repair tape or a method approved by the manufacturer; larger damage is resolved with a welded patch or cushion replacement. After repair, the zone's pressure and behaviour are checked again and the result is recorded in the maintenance log.
Technical FAQ
View complete FAQDoes hail puncture ETFE foil?
ETFE foil is very elastic, and a cushion at design pressure absorbs most impacts by deforming. A puncture is still possible, depending on hailstone size and speed, outer-layer thickness, cushion geometry and above all the internal pressure at the moment of impact. That is why an inspection is needed after heavy hail, even if nothing is visible from below.
If one cushion layer is punctured, will the roof collapse?
Usually not. In a multi-layer cushion, a small hole usually causes an air leak, and the air unit compensates by increasing airflow; the inner layers also keep the interior separated. But this compensation is temporary: the fans run continuously and the safety margin in the next wind or snow event falls. The hole has to be repaired, not left to the fans.
Why does cushion air pressure matter so much during hail?
Because the cushion's stiffness comes from its internal pressure. At design pressure the cushion is taut and spreads the impact; a soft cushion sags, holds hail and water in a hollow and concentrates load. A blocked filter, a faulty fan or a power cut without backup creates exactly this condition at the worst possible moment.
Can holes in ETFE foil be repaired on site?
Yes. Small holes and tears are usually repaired in place with dedicated ETFE repair tape. This suits minor damage and does not match the strength of the original weld; larger tears need a welded patch on site or replacement of the whole cushion. The repair method and materials should be approved by the system manufacturer.
Is the noise of hail under an ETFE roof normal?
Yes. Light, taut foil transmits the impact noise of rain and hail clearly to the space below, and the noise alone is not a sign of damage. Where it is a problem for the use of the space, options such as a rain-noise suppression layer over the cushions exist, but they should be chosen after an acoustic assessment and with their effect on cleaning and maintenance in mind.
After a hailstorm, what should an owner do, and what should they avoid?
Check and record the air-unit alarms and fan status, photograph any slack or distorted cushions from below, and check gutters and water outlets. Never walk on the foil, never chip ice off with a sharp tool and never patch a damaged cushion yourself; close inspection and repair should be carried out by a trained team with safe access.
Related Engineering Resources
Open resource hubA project-stage checklist for reviewing slope, drainage, flashings, penetrations, gutters, and installation risk before roofing starts.
Sandwich Panel Selection GuideA decision guide for choosing panel type, core material, thickness, joint logic, insulation level, and procurement inputs before ordering.
Project ProofReview verified SIPANEL project references without invented results.
Related Services and Insights
CTA
Before the next hail or snow, review your ETFE cushions and air network
Send the roof documents, the foil and air-unit specifications, the alarm history and photos of suspect cushions, and SIPANEL's technical team will review pressure, air-network redundancy, drainage and damaged areas and propose a repair or correction approach.